Comparing Xfinity vs ADT Home Security System: Which is Best for You in 2023?

Home security system overlooking a house

Comcast’s Xfinity and ADT are both recognized names in the home security industry, but they have very different business models, offerings, and reputations. The decision as to which company is best for you depends largely on your needs and goals; however, it can be difficult to wade through all of the available information about these two companies to determine what factors are most important to you. This guide will help you compare Xfinity vs ADT so that you can make an informed decision based on your personal preferences.

Comparing ADT vs Xfinity is essential if you are wanting to know what the best in home security has to offer in 2022. Finding the right home security systems with professional installation is key to feeling safe at home. When considering different professional monitoring security systems, both ADT and Xfinity home security systems come to mind as well-established brands on the market.

Xfinity vs ADT Comparison

Gold Scales

So, if you are looking for a professional monitoring security system to make your home more safe and secure, which brand is better? In this guide, we’ll take you through the key similarities and differences between both ADT and Xfinity home security systems so you can make an informed decision as to which is best for your needs.

With security equipment including door and window sensors and options for mobile app control, both brands are considered to be the best self monitored home security system available on the market. Read on to find out which might be better for your needs.

Comcast Xfinity Home Security

Xfinity Home Security Hub

First up, let’s take a look at the Xfinity home security system.

It offers professional monitoring, so you’ll always be at the top of the home security game, 24 hours a day. In terms of equipment, the package includes some door or window sensors and a motion sensor. This motion detector can be used to differentiate between pets, people, and vehicles, so you can set it up according to your needs.

The equipment itself is fairly typical, but the method of control is where Xfinity home security excels. The Xfinity Home app is excellent, whether used on an iOS or Android device. This means you can access the control panel remotely, wherever you may be.

You can also use your Xfinity Home system to adjust a smart thermostat. This means your house will always be warm for you coming home from work, without wasting too much heat when you are away from home.

Xfinity offers much more than just home security – you can bundle everything including your phone, cable TV, and internet together with home security in one low-price package. Not only will you save money, but it’s also a lot less hassle to have everything in one place and with one company.

ADT Home Security

ADT security sign in yard

We’ve covered the basics of the Xfinity home system, so now it’s time to turn to the ADT home security system. ADT is, without a doubt, the biggest name in home security – it’s the go-to option if you’re looking for a brand you can trust.

As a result, the high-quality equipment you’ll get is some of the best in the industry. With professional installation, you can be sure everything is up and running as it should be. As one of the best security systems, ADT offers 24/7 monitoring centers so you can be sure you are always protected as much as possible.

There is loads of equipment available, with optional add-ons to tailor your package to your home and family. The pet-friendly motion sensor will ensure your dogs and cats can roam around at home without accidentally tripping the burglar alarm. The alarm is controlled by a wireless keypad and includes door and window sensors. CCTV security cameras and doorbell cameras are available for you to keep an eye on your home from anywhere.

With ADT Pulse, the company’s mobile app, you can use the smart home features, like turning smart lights on or off, as well as watching your outdoor cameras.

Xfinity vs. ADT Comparison Overview

When performing an ADT and Xfinity comparison, we’re going to take a look at various key categories and features. We’ll compare aspects such as;

  • Included equipment and its quality
  • Installation and monitoring options
  • Overall costs and contract lengths

Xfinity vs. ADT comparison

So, ADT vs. Xfinity, which performs better? We’re now going to compare the two home services across various categories so you can decide which might better suit your needs.

Home security equipment included

Security cameras on a wall

Both ADT and Xfinity Home include similar equipment as standard in their complete package. Both come with a few window and door sensors, motion detectors, and control panels and remotes to deactivate the system.

With Xfinity, you can add gear like indoor or outdoor night vision cameras and smart home automation equipment like the Zen thermostat.

ADT offers additional security equipment including a camera and more sensors, such as the glass-break sensor, ideal for sliding doors.

So, both companies offer a great choice of security equipment – it’s up to you to decide which pieces you might need the most.

Installation and monitoring services

Homeowner installing security camera

Both ADT and Xfinity systems have to be installed professionally – there’s no do-it-yourself option with either. This means you can be sure everything is working properly, although you will have to book an appointment and pay a fee for this service.

In terms of monitoring services, both offer 24/7 professional monitoring. However, there is only one option with Xfinity, whereas ADT has more choice. With ADT, you can enjoy cellular backup, video monitoring, and much more.

Both offer smart home options – ADT’s service, ADT Pulse, and Xfinity’s Home app are both easy to use.

So, ADT is better if you want more choice and to tailor your monitoring to your needs. However, Xfinity is unbeatable when it comes to price. So, if you are happy with the single package on offer, you might find Xfinity a better choice.

Contract lengths, upfront cost, and overall cost

Close Up of Pen on Contract

Unfortunately, both companies require long-term contracts. The minimum with Xfinity is 24 months, and with ADT, you’ll be tied in for 36 months.

Xfinity offers a 30-day return period. However, the longer contract might be worth it if you need more time to decide – ADT gives you a massive six months in which to get your money back if you are not satisfied.

Neither company charges upfront for the equipment, but the monthly costs do vary between the two. Xfinity offers a lower price of $29.99 per month in the first year, which increases to $39.99 per month in the second year of the contract.

ADT charges up to $199 for the installation of the system, then the monthly cost ranges from around $40 to $60, depending on the package and services you have chosen.

Remember, it’s not just about the cost – think about value for money, too. In the case of home security, you’ll get what you pay for, so it’s not always best to go for the cheaper option. It could be worthwhile to pay more for ADT’s services – read the rest of our guide to decide which company offers the better service for your needs.

Key differences between Xfinity vs. ADT

Group of paper airplane in one direction and with one individual pointing in the different way

ADT offers an excellent security system for your home, as does Xfinity. So, what’s different about the two companies? Here’s where the two vary somewhat;

  • ADT is ranked much higher in terms of customer service. Xfinity performs quite poorly in this regard, according to surveys and research.
  • ADT has a larger customer base and is certainly the better-known home security company.
  • Xfinity offers better smart home integration options.
  • Xfinity is generally cheaper after considering installation fees and overall costs throughout the contract.
  • There are more options with ADT, including cellular, whereas ADT relies on high-speed internet.

As you can see, there are a few fields in which one company outperforms the other. So, the features you prioritize will have a bearing on which home security company you might like to protect your home with.

Main similarities between ADT vs. Xfinity

wooden cubes with icon business strategy on blue background.

Whatever home security service you choose, you can be sure your home will be well-protected. There are many similarities between the services offered by both companies. Here are just a few;

  • Professional installation required
  • Long-term contracts required
  • Smart home and mobile app compatibility
  • 24/7 monitoring

Home Security System FAQs

Still have questions about choosing the best self monitoring home security system equipment? We have everything else you need to know when comparing ADT vs. Xfinity below.

What does ADT offer that Xfinity does not?

We’ve seen above that both ADT and Xfinity make great options when it comes to home security. However, there are a couple of things you’ll find with an ADT home security system that aren’t available to those going with Xfinity.

ADT uses a cellular connection, so you don’t have to have fast and reliable home Wi-Fi to remain connected to the network in the event of an emergency. Also, ADT is one of the biggest and best-known names in home security. So, it’s no surprise that their equipment is perhaps the best quality the industry has to offer.

Which home security system should you choose?

It really comes down to your home’s needs and the budget you have available for your home security system.

Overall, ADT offers the best home security systems with the highest-quality equipment and lots of extra features. However, if you are already a Comcast customer for other services, you might find it better to go for Xfinity. You can go for an Xfinity bundle to save some money on your home security, cable TV, and internet services.

What is best, Xfinity or ADT home security?

Both are solid choices, but ADT slightly outperforms Xfinity in several categories. This trustworthy name offers the ultimate home system with top-of-the-range security equipment and a long money-back guarantee to ensure you are satisfied with the service. You’ll also get great customer service with ADT, which is always a nice bonus when you have to get in touch with the company.

How much do ADT and Xfinity cost? Which is cheaper?

A complete home system is never going to be cheap, but first-class home security is always worth investing in.

The monthly fees vary slightly between each company, but both protect you with a money-back guarantee.

Let’s first take a look at the costs of an ADT home security system. Depending on the features and standard of security equipment you want to include, the cost will vary slightly. Customers generally pay between $40-$60 per month for an ADT system. The company provides a six-month money-back guarantee should you find the service unsuitable for your needs.

If you want a more basic monitoring system, you’ll be looking at around $40 per month. The higher end of the price scale includes home automation features and live video monitoring – you get what you pay for.

On the other hand, Xfinity will generally cost slightly less. During your first year as a Comcast customer, your home security system will cost $29.99 per month. However, going into your second year, there will be a $10 per month price increase.

Also, Xfinity offers a shorter guarantee. Customers are only protected for 30 days from when their contract starts – meaning you have less time to decide if the professional monitoring service is right for you or not. However, the minimum contract length with Xfinity is two years; with ADT, it’s three years.

So, Xfinity will probably work out cheaper over the course of a few years, but you have less protection if you are not impressed with the service.

Can both Xfinity and ADT call the police in emergencies?

Yes, both systems can be used to immediately contact the police in the event of a break-in or other emergency at your home.

This is because both ADT and Xfinity have 24/7 professional monitoring. Your home alarm system is connected to a wider network, so an employee of the security company will be notified of the alarm sounding.

Don’t worry; false alarms will be monitored too. The police will only be called in the event of a genuine situation – the security staff will decide whether or not to alert the authorities.

Do ADT and Xfinity systems work without a monitoring service?

Not really. The best security solution is one with constant monitoring, so if you don’t want to pay the monthly fee for this service, your home will be less protected.

Without the monitoring service, you won’t benefit from alerts to the ADT or Xfinity Home app, and your home security system won’t be able to automatically contact the police if there is an incident.

However, you will still be able to access more basic features without the monitoring service. This includes sounding an alarm in the event of a break-in.

More comparison Articles and Review Guides to Consider:

Simplisafe vs ADT: Comparing Home Security Systems

Ring vs SimpliSafe


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here